RealPagan

"Black" and "White" Magic – RealPagan- Paganism for the Real World

"Black" and "White" Magic

So...... I have seen a lot of comments and questions in discussion, chat, and blogs on several sites pertaining to "black" and "white" magic. I have seen newbies ask whether they should avoid books because they contain "black magic" and seen members refer to themselves and "white witches." Black magic does not exist, neither does white. Nor does green, or blue, or any other color you can imagine. Magic is magic. It's really that simple. I understand that some people utilize these terms to seperate what they consider harmful magic from benign magic. However, I do not believe the two can be seperated. All magic has the potentiality for harm. Now, I know that some will say, "But it's your intent that really matters." However, any spell or magic can cause unintentional harm. Say you cast a spell to help a friend escape an abusive relationship, and then the abuser is killed in a car wreck, was your spell white or black?? Or maybe somewhere in between?? In addition, "harm" or "bad" are subjective. Completely subjective. What one person considers "bad" may be a wonderful thing for another person. So, who decides which consequences are "good" and which are "bad" and thus what magic is "black" and what magic is "white" ??? Without drawing clear lines with dogma, this task is impossible. Some of you will say, "But there are books on Black and White Magic!" And I hope these people will realize that the title of a book is a marketing tool. "Black Magic" books are written and marketed inorder to appeal to a particular audience, as are "White Magic" books. In addition, in my opinion, you should never avoid a book or a topic because it makes you uneasy or frightens you. The only way to fight fear is with knowledge. There is no "black magic." There is no "white magic." I wonder how everyone else feels??
Load Previous Comments
  • Strata

    Stonewolf, I completely understand what you are trying to say, but manipulating a *person* whether a specific person or a non-specific person is manipulation, end of story.  And manipulating a person effects their free-will.  Events *might* be a little different, but not always.  If you are manipulating events, you may have manipulated a person to put those events into play.  I find that the less specific your magic is the more chances there are for the unexpected.  Which brings me back to my original point.  There is no "good" or "bad" magic as all has the potential for harm.  And as these terms are subjective the concept itself becomes so.  Therefore,  there are no forms of magic that are definitively "good" or "bad."
  • Strata

    So why is specific magic called "Black" by this definition??  By the more traditional, the one that this blog addresses, at least it makes logical sense...even if it is wrong.  Black has negative connotations.. black represents "evil" and "bad" to many cultures and people.  So used to represent presumed "bad" magic at least the title makes sense.  Why call specific magic "black?"
  • Strata

    The point of this blog being that the intent does not anyways matter.  Magic can have unexpected consequences.  Even if your intent is *good*, in your opinion, all the consequences may not be.

     

    Also, if you are going to post author's opinions in my blogs in the future please be prepared with the author's name and title of the book.  I cannot find that book by a Caskaris or similar name for reference.