Nevermind the misspelling witch behind the curtain

It really is annoying when ever I hear or see the red herring terminology like this little gem I found online, by someone in my area who promotes himself as a local leader and is taking students, for a minimal fee, to teach Craft:

"I call what I teach, a modified form of Gardinarian Wicca. What that means is that I use traditional methods for teaching, and very traditional forms for ritual. Any Gardinarian coming to my ritual would immediately recognize it... The difference is that I have modified some elements in ways that work better for me. This is the basis of Witchcraft..."

Yeah.  That. 

So my fellow pointy-hatted many things are wrong with this diatribe?  Let's count, shall we?

ONE:  This guy charges for training in the Craft --- this in and of itself tells me that he hasn't had British Traditional Training, because if he had, he'd know we don't ever charge for training.  It is bad form, bad juju, bad manners.  If he is teaching his own form of the Craft, he can do what he likes in so far as charging for it ---although as a potential student, how would you know the value of the teaching is worth the cost of the class?--- but his stuff isn't BTW-based then, since he's ascribed a financial value to it.

TWO:  Spelling it 'Gardinarian' is a sure-fire way to say you are either too lazy to spell-check Gerald Gardner's name and thus the namesake tradition....or else you were being purposefully sneaky by not using the correct spelling, thereby giving yourself the ability to say "I used a variant of old Gerald's name to denote my stuff is a variant of the real Garderian tradition." 

That latter bit then brings us to...

THREE:  Saying your stuff is a variant of something to which you are not privy is ridiculous.  It is impossible to truly know what encompasses Gardnerian traditional Craft practice unless you are an initiate of that how can you say yours is a variant of something you do not know first hand??!?  Moreover, you wouldn't be exposed to all of the teachings of a Gardnerian tradition unless you were brought all the way through to 3rd Degree, and then given permission to teach it, with duly made oaths to not expose what you've been foresworn in your practice and revelatory experience to others, unless they too are proper people, given similar initiation into the tradition and likewise foresworn to protect it? 

Thus, what we have here is someone once again wanting the "pagan street cred" of claiming knowledge of things he may only have barest gleanings about, then making assumptions and suppositions about those little bits and then "making it his own" in some fashion and claiming his is a "modified version" of the whole encompassing reality of a tradition to which he isn't a member.


I think not.

But there are folks like this out there, gang.  Still.  They think people like me --the people who call them out on their verbal slight-of-hand and dubious integrity in Craft teaching--- they think I AM A BIG MEANIE POOPYHEAD. 

With all due respect, I'm just protecting my tribe, my tradition, good sir.  I'm doing what my oaths say by shining a big spotlight on you.

And if you DID have the initiation you claimed to have, you'd know this.  You'd know better.

Go do you your own Craft thing.  Go teach others, and do so with all good intention and aplomb.  I applaud you and wish you all good success.

Just stop trying to ascribe some vague notion of that my tradition, however you may bastardize its spelling, is a "stamp of approval" toward what you're doing.



Views: 37

Tags: Fraudernarians, frauds, integrity_wanted, trust-your-gut

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of RealPagan- Paganism for the Real World to add comments!

Join RealPagan- Paganism for the Real World

Comment by Ariel Roxi on January 18, 2017 at 9:55

Thank you for this post. It was very well thought out and clearly explained. I hope you would post this out there were seekers are so that they are not being scammed and shammed. I have been in the craft for many years and have been fortunate enough to live in an area with some wonderful elders. Though I started out practicing and learning alone it was a real treasure to meet, learn and practice with some wonderful people. But I can see where it is such a simple thing to take advantage of those seeking knowledge. They don't know what to expect and can easily be "sold" a bunch of hooey not to mention that they can be taken advantage of in other ways as well.  Cheers to you for sharing.  

Comment by Steve Paine on December 1, 2016 at 17:12

I couldn't agree more Albania! 

Comment by MarcusAgrippa1 on November 30, 2016 at 18:51

Let me start first My Lady with a big thank you for this blog.  I had started me thinking again about the problem of the cost of teaching and learning.

While most traditions agree that teaching for a monetary feel is if not at least bad manners, there remains a questions as should the student be expected to pay a price.

I would suggest that any serious student would expect at least to invest in their own education in the form of books and tools as well as their time and effort.  The concept of 'free education' is worth exactly that --- zero.  Unless one is willing to expend of themselves in the search for knowledge and development; there is little to be gained.    This investment in oneself and ones spiritual growth is rewarded continually by the Eternal One in many forms.

So thank you for upholding the principle of our shared tradition.  I would ask that we also tell the student what is expected of them before they start.  And then when they understand and accept that -- let the teaching begin.

    Blessed be,  aka Nestor


Steve Paine created this Ning Network.

© 2017   Created by Steve Paine.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

The Pagan Top Sites List